TNF Reaction - Questions Abound for Raiders

Questions Abound for the Raiders
By Dylan Ehle

Rich Gannon.  Jerry Rice.  Tim Brown.  Bill Romanowski.  Seems like a long time ago, doesn’t it?

Well, it has been a long time.  It’s been a decade since the aforementioned Raiders players won the AFC championship game against the Titans to take the Raiders to Super Bowl XXXVII.  Since Bill Callahan reaped the rewards of the team that Gruden built and took them to the big dance – where, as we all know, they ironically lost to Gruden - the Raiders have been completely irrelevant.  The Raiders have one of the most dedicated fan bases in football today, and that’s incredible if you take a look at what they’ve had to deal with in the past decade:

2003: 4-12
2004: 5-11
2005: 4-12
2006: 2-14
2007: 4-12
2008: 5-11
2009: 5-11
2010: 8-8
2011: 8-8
2012: 3-10 to date

Seriously.  Love or hate the Raiders all you want, but the fact that fans can be so dedicated in the face of such horrible performances is truly remarkable.  The Raiders are a storied franchise which holds three Super Bowl rings and one AFL championship, and they truly were a team to be feared in the 80s.  They had so many legendary games with the Steelers during that span, and they continued to be a threat through the 90s and early 00s.  After that Super Bowl appearance, though, a star-studded Raiders cast quickly became populated with lethargic players and horrible busts:  Randy Moss, LaMont Jordan, Jerry Porter, and the infamous JaMarcus Russell, just to name just a few.  

Things seemed to take a turn for the better for the Raiders in 2010, though.  The defense was more solid, led by the play of shutdown corner Nnamdi Asomugha.  The editions of RB Darren McFadden and speedy WRs Denarius Moore and Darrius Hayward-Bey gave the Raiders’ offense several home-run threats every time their offense touched the ball.  I got a good look at this team when they played the Jags in November of 2010.  The teams got into a complete shootout (and shootouts are rare in Jags games….when there are a lot of points on the board, usually most belong to the other team, and it’s more correctly called a rout).  Anyway, this game featured back and forth scoring, and a horrible lack of defense.  It may have been the best game of Darren McFadden’s career, as he broke tackle after tackle, hitting the second level in the defense or turning the corner up the sideline for extra yards and first downs.  The Jags came back and won the game, but I was shocked at how much grit the Raiders showed.  Like everyone else, I had been clumping the Raiders into the bottom-5 teams in the NFL for the past 7 years, I had loved to see them on the Jags' schedule – it made an impression on me to see some real playmakers on the field for Oakland.

Then came 2011.  The Raiders lost their icon, Al Davis, and won a huge game against the Texans the ensuing week in his honor.  Shortly thereafter came the big trade for Carson Palmer.  I thought that the Raiders gave up WAY too much to get him.  I know they were panicking when Jason Campbell went down (watching his play this year for the Bears, you have to wonder why anyone would panic upon losing him) and they were trying to save their season, but seriously….two first-round draft picks?!  That’s far too much.  That’s approaching what the Redskins gave up to get RG3, and that was for a rookie with his whole career ahead of him, not a veteran who has had multiple serious injuries throughout his career and only had a few years left to play.  

The Raiders needed those draft picks to build their future.  If their team had been more solidified and they were just a QB away, the move would have made a lot more sense, but few people thought that the Raiders would make the playoffs last year, let alone challenge for the Super Bowl.  On the flip side, the Bengals cashed in on their former QB, who was going to retire rather than finish out his contract.  They used the picks from the Raiders to have one of the best drafts of 2012, which included top prospects Kevin Zeitler, Dre Kirkpatrick, and Mohammed Sanu.  Palmer has been below average in his time with the Raiders, and has only put together 7 wins in the season and a half since his arrival.  While he gives the Raiders much more of a vertical threat than they’ve had in recent years, he throws so many interceptions that it completely negates it.

Facing their tenth straight losing season, the Raiders have to take a really hard look at their roster.  While Al Davis brought a ton of energy to the franchise, he had a habit for going after flashy players in both the draft and in free agency who didn’t pan out.  The Raiders need to use these last few games to evaluate that talent and see what players are worth keeping.  Davis gave up a third round pick in the supplemental draft for Terrelle Pryor – you already know what you’re getting with Palmer, so why not play Pryor for a few games to see what he can do?  Darren McFadden’s contract is coming up – the back has been injury prone, but he’s healthy now, so use him heavily to see what he can do.  Use Moore and Heyward-Bey to stretch the field and see if they can actually haul in the deep passes consistently or if they are just combine speed freaks.   The Raiders have many holes on their roster already, and need to know if any of these players will get them by as they build in other areas, or if they present glaring positional needs that needs to addressed immediately.

After promising 2010 and 2011 campaigns, 2012 has unfortunately painted a bleak picture for the upcoming few seasons for Raiders fans.  Hopefully, new ownership will use these last three games to build up some film on their players to do a thorough offseason evaluation of the talent to expedite the rebuilding process.  Only then will one of the NFL’s most storied franchises return to glory.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      

No comments:

Post a Comment